spacer

Welcome Guest ( Log In | Register )

> Guidelines

Please keep posts tasteful and appropriate for all audiences - we will not tolerate any obscene language, flaming or trolling. Besides that, make sure you read the forum rules here before you post.

 
Digg this topic Save to del.icio.us Submit to Reddit Slashdot It
Reply to this topicStart new topic
> Iraq Study Group Report, A.k.a. Why the f*** are we in Iraq?
Crazy Gringo
post 6th December 2006, 3:25pm
Post #1


War is hell and war never changes therefore hell never changes
****

Group: Site Staff
Posts: 512
Joined: October 2003
From: Malmö, Sweden
Member No.: 1,577



Yep the report is out and I just thought I might share Lou Dobbs thoughts on the wars in Iraq/Afghanistan/War on terror.
Link.


--------------------
Words to live by from Sergent Gunnery Highway: ' You adapt, improvise and overcome!'

'To kill a dream it is not enough to kill the dreamer', -Quote by Crazy Gringo until proven otherwise.

Mental Father of Air Morelman and Air Wargot!

Official StrategyCore UFO: Afterlight previewer. Preview here!

Has joined the league of 'The Crazy 8800s'
Go to the top of the page
 
+Quote Post
Accounting Troll
post 6th December 2006, 7:06pm
Post #2


Bridge troll
*****

Group: Admin
Posts: 1,057
Joined: October 2003
From: Wales
Member No.: 1,341



I think pride has become a big factor in the continuing Anglo-American presence in Iraq.

The idea that the reconstruction of Iraq would have been self funding due to oil revenues would have been correct had it not been for the insurgency. Britain and the USA overestimated the support we would get from the Iraqi people in the aftermath of the fall of Saddam Hussein. The support we did get ebbed away when we failed to find Iraqi WMDs, mistreated prisoners and demonstrated that many of our soldiers have little understanding or respect of the local culture and politics.

Bush and Blair keep telling us the thing they want to believe - that the insurgency will be crushed within a few months and that the Iraqi forces are almost ready to take over the situation themeselves. They simply cannot bring themselves to admit, even to themselves, that their Middle Eastern policies are a failure.
Go to the top of the page
 
+Quote Post
Zombie
post 6th December 2006, 10:09pm
Post #3


Mr. Grognard
*****

Group: Admin
Posts: 2,858
Joined: January 2004
From: Sheboygan WI, USA
Member No.: 1,322



I don't know about this. Really, think about it for a second. The Middle East has always had a complete and utter hatred to the United States. Doesn't matter what the reasons are anymore as the hatred runs deep. (It's probably religious intolerance as that always plays a role). Removing the leader of a group may suddenly choke the resistance due to shock and morale loss but it will return in time if the people are loyal. And c'mon, who really thought that a democratic government could ever rule Iraq? It's an impossibility. The people have to want it. You can't suddenly force-feed democracy down someones throat when they have been brought up to believe that a dictatorship is is a better form of government. This has to be done very slowly (if at all). Will Iraq ever be ruled by a stable democratic government? I'd like to think so, but it wouldn't be in my lifetime. wink.gif

- Zombie


--------------------

QUOTE(JellyfishGreen)
Zombie: Empirical data's your only man, when formulating a research plan.
A soldier's death is never in vain if it makes the formula more plain.
A few dozen make a better case for refining that third decimal place.
They call me Zombie because I don't sleep, as I slowly struggle to climb this heap,
of corpses, data points, and trials, but from the top - I'll see for miles!
Go to the top of the page
 
+Quote Post
Crazy Gringo
post 6th December 2006, 11:12pm
Post #4


War is hell and war never changes therefore hell never changes
****

Group: Site Staff
Posts: 512
Joined: October 2003
From: Malmö, Sweden
Member No.: 1,577



All this talking about democracy brings to mind something I once pondered over. What is the alternative to democracy? But I think the real question should be: 'What is the next step in the evolution of forms of goverment after democracy has become old and obsolete?'
The concept of goverment works fine in an 'western' enviroment where you have what I would call 'civilization' and/or have an well established and functional society.
The democratic nations of the world today has been undergoing couple of 100 years of headstart to build up their functioning and well oiled societies that they are today.
If you try to squeeze a couple of 100 years of progress/evolution down a country's throat it might backfire and set an regression chain of events in motion where the people of the country revert to their 'older' and more 'safe' ideals. Along with the usual fight for the power struggle when a power vacuum emerges.


--------------------
Words to live by from Sergent Gunnery Highway: ' You adapt, improvise and overcome!'

'To kill a dream it is not enough to kill the dreamer', -Quote by Crazy Gringo until proven otherwise.

Mental Father of Air Morelman and Air Wargot!

Official StrategyCore UFO: Afterlight previewer. Preview here!

Has joined the league of 'The Crazy 8800s'
Go to the top of the page
 
+Quote Post
FullAuto
post 7th December 2006, 1:59am
Post #5


Catching the next pimpmobile outta here!
*****

Group: Chief Editor
Posts: 1,789
Joined: August 2003
From: UK
Member No.: 417



Apparently, the report recommends reducing political, economic and military aid if Iraq doesn't meet its goals.

How on Earth that is going to help the situation is beyond me. Perhaps they mean just for a short while, to teach them what happens when they don't do as they're told.


--------------------
Whooooo wants some WANG!?
Go to the top of the page
 
+Quote Post
DeepOne
post 7th December 2006, 9:04am
Post #6


Squaddie
*

Group: Members
Posts: 12
Joined: October 2004
Member No.: 289



QUOTE(Crazy Gringo @ 6th December 2006, 11:12pm) *
All this talking about democracy brings to mind something I once pondered over. What is the alternative to democracy?

Muslims tend to want Sharia Law.
Go to the top of the page
 
+Quote Post
Crazy Gringo
post 7th December 2006, 3:24pm
Post #7


War is hell and war never changes therefore hell never changes
****

Group: Site Staff
Posts: 512
Joined: October 2003
From: Malmö, Sweden
Member No.: 1,577



QUOTE(DeepOne @ 7th December 2006, 10:04am) *
QUOTE(Crazy Gringo @ 6th December 2006, 11:12pm) *

All this talking about democracy brings to mind something I once pondered over. What is the alternative to democracy?

Muslims tend to want Sharia Law.

You mean this?
Interesting reading if you keep going deeper.
But I was more thinking in the lines of this.


--------------------
Words to live by from Sergent Gunnery Highway: ' You adapt, improvise and overcome!'

'To kill a dream it is not enough to kill the dreamer', -Quote by Crazy Gringo until proven otherwise.

Mental Father of Air Morelman and Air Wargot!

Official StrategyCore UFO: Afterlight previewer. Preview here!

Has joined the league of 'The Crazy 8800s'
Go to the top of the page
 
+Quote Post

Reply to this topicStart new topic
1 User(s) are reading this topic (1 Guests and 0 Anonymous Users)
0 Members:

 

Collapse

> Similar Topics

    Topic Title Replies Topic Starter Views Last Action
No New Posts   5 Shifty 388 23rd July 2003, 2:13am
Last post by: Shifty
No new 16 BladeFireLight 1,303 18th May 2004, 7:16pm
Last post by: maxoman
No New Posts   0 ooda 222 17th October 2002, 1:39pm
Last post by: ooda
No New Posts 11 61cygni 951 16th October 2003, 5:46pm
Last post by: Pete
No New Posts   12 BReilley 893 29th May 2005, 1:36pm
Last post by: Slaughter

RSS Lo-Fi Version Time is now: 23rd November 2008, 12:33pm